NEW WEBINAR: Leading Through Conflict: Practical Strategies for Campus Leaders
Register Now
Blog
Peter T Coleman

Conflict Is a Leadership Skill: A Conversation with Dr. Peter T. Coleman

Category:Interview
CDI Team|November 16, 2026

What should campus leaders do when a conflict tests their community, and what should they do in preparation long before it does?

We spoke with Dr. Peter T. Coleman, Professor of Psychology and Education at Columbia University, about how leaders can prepare for, respond to, and recover from campus conflict. In this conversation, Peter argues that the hardest conflicts behave less like emergencies and more like chronic conditions.

Before Crises Occur

Q: Campus conflict planning is often crisis planning: what to do when the encampment appears. What should a campus be doing in the months before anything happens, and why does that work get skipped?

Most conflict resolution advice is like emergency medicine: diagnose, treat, resolve (see our RESCUE model here). But our hardest conflicts behave more like chronic public-health problems. The ER clinician treats the patient in the room (the live dispute). The public-health practitioner asks why this neighborhood keeps getting sick and changes the stressors that keep producing ailing patients. This approach is much less well known, so this work tends to be neglected. Think of it like peace building meets organizational development. Our research on Conflict Intelligence describes these two very different strategies, and how to decide when to use each. It is critical to know the difference.

Q: When a leader is in the middle of a live conflict and under pressure to respond within hours, what is the first thing they should do, and what is the most common mistake they make in that window?

Of course, this depends on the leader and the timing and magnitude of the conflict.

However, busy leaders often tend to react (or overreact) rather automatically to what can feel like a threatening situation. These conditions often lead to regretful responses that bring unintended consequences.

Conflict-Intelligent leaders understand the power that lives between a stimulus and response (thank you, Viktor Frankl). That is, the capacity to take a minute when conflict strikes, reflect on your objectives in the situation – and even on the potential consequences of overreacting – and choose a response intentionally. This ain’t easy, and often requires practice. But we have found that this competency – which we call Steadiness – pays great dividends for leaders and their institutions.

Conflict Resolution and Relationship Repair Require Different Approaches

Q: Once a relationship between an administration and its community has been damaged, is repairing it a different task from managing the original conflict? What does repair actually consist of?

Yes, conflict resolution and relationship repair after a rupture – especially between large institutions and their internal or surrounding communities – are different challenges requiring different approaches. Of course, it depends on what harms have been experienced, as some will require legal remedies. But there are specific types of processes aimed at reconciliation between groups – like restorative justice forums – that can be very useful with intact communities that wish and need to stay together and improve relations.

Beyond these processes, institutions may require some significant structural changes to address the underlying drivers the conflicts (see this article).

Q: Leaders tend to judge whether trust has been rebuilt by whether the campus is quiet. Is that the right measure, and if not, what should they be looking at?

Absolutely not. A quiet campus can mean an alienated and disengaged community. This may feel more manageable, but if there are simmering tensions, they’ll be back!

We need better trackers. Most universities tend to be challenged when it comes to collecting and effectively using data on social climate. Such measures can be very useful for getting a bead on whether or not trust or distrust are increasing or decreasing, but only when the data is collected efficiently (using tools like short pulse surveys, behavioral data to assess trends, plus annual surveys), and effectively utilized to inform policy decisions and communications. This is ideal, especially in our era of social media when a noisy few of the more extreme influencers tend to drive impressions of the status of the entire enterprise. Best to have good data to counteract such narratives.

Q: A university has to protect sharp disagreement and keep a community functioning at the same time. Do you see those as in tension, or is open disagreement part of how a community stays healthy?

It depends on the ratio. If all that happens at a university is criticism, competition, debate, and attack, it will die. Any community – a college, a sports team, a company, or a motorcycle gang – needs connection, care and compassion as a baseline. In the context of such respect and rapport, sharp disagreements can serve a genuine purpose.

John Gottman has found that for marriages to thrive, there needs to be a 5:1 ratio of positivity-to-negativity – especially during conflict. But couples need conflict in order to learn and change and grow. We have found that conversations between strangers over moral disagreements require a 3:1 ratio to be constructive enough that people want them to continue. This finding also scales to societies. We have also found that media accounts of intergroup interactions from high-peace vs low-peace societies differ by their ratios of positive intergroup reciprocity to negative. The negative encounters often serve as a healthy check-and-balance – but only when they are accompanied by sufficient good will.


About Peter

Dr. Peter T. Coleman is Professor of Psychology and Education at Columbia University, where he directs the Morton Deutsch International Center for Cooperation and Conflict Resolution and serves as co-executive director of the Advanced Consortium on Cooperation, Conflict, and Complexity. His books include The Five Percent; Making Conflict Work, winner of the 2016 Outstanding Book Award from the International Association of Conflict Management; and The Way Out: How to Overcome Toxic Polarization. He serves on the UN Mediation Support Unit’s Academic Advisory Council and is a New York State certified mediator.

Share:

Follow Our Work

Sign up for our higher education newsletter to get regular updates on our research, product releases, and the science & practice of constructive dialogue.

Privacy Notice

This site uses cookies. Please click accept to continue, or visit our Privacy Policy to learn more.